What did I think?
I went into You Deserve Each Other expecting a fun, quirky rom-com with a bit of bite, but instead I found myself slogging through a story filled with characters who seemed perpetually miserable. The premise had so much potential: an engaged couple, Naomi and Nicholas, realize they can’t stand each other anymore and basically start waging war in an effort to make the other call off the wedding. It should have been sharp, witty, and entertaining. Instead, I just felt like I was trapped at dinner with two people who don’t know how to communicate and seem to take joy in making each other’s lives worse.
Naomi is the main character and, while I understood her frustrations, I found it exhausting to be in her head for so long. Her bitterness seeped into everything. Nicholas was supposed to be the counterbalance, but he came across as smug and withholding. Together, they just didn’t spark in a way that made me root for them. I kept waiting for the moment where their banter would feel more playful than cruel, but for most of the book, it just felt mean-spirited.
Why didn’t it work for me?
Part of it comes down to tone. Some readers have described this as a darkly funny, enemies-to-lovers-within-a-relationship kind of story, and I get that. I can see why others found the toxicity entertaining or cathartic. But for me, it crossed into uncomfortable territory. The pettiness wasn’t funny, it was draining. Instead of cheering for Naomi and Nicholas to rediscover love, I was secretly hoping they would just call the whole thing off and find new partners who actually brought out the best in them.
Another issue is that the side characters weren’t much better. There’s a heavy dose of awkward family dynamics and secondary relationships that all seemed rooted in manipulation or passive aggression. By the midpoint, I realized there wasn’t really anyone in this book that I wanted to spend time with.
Who might like it?
If you enjoy romance that takes a much darker, snarkier approach to love, this might actually be right up your alley. I’ve seen plenty of readers describe this book as refreshing because it dares to show an already-established couple dealing with all the ugliness that can come from resentment and poor communication. If you’re someone who enjoys seeing characters behave badly and then, somehow, still stumble their way toward growth and reconciliation, you’ll probably enjoy the ride.
Final thoughts
For me, You Deserve Each Other was a frustrating read. The humor missed the mark, the characters felt more toxic than relatable, and I never got the sense that their relationship was something worth saving. That said, I also recognize that I’m in the minority. Many readers found it laugh-out-loud funny and refreshingly different from your standard romance novel. If you’re curious, it might be worth trying, but go in knowing that the characters are not sunshine-and-rainbows people. Personally, I closed the book feeling more drained than entertained.
Discover more from itsm3g
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.