The Women in White by Sarah Pekkanen: The Real Science Behind Zener Cards, ESP, and Why Smart People Believed

The 1964 storyline in Sarah Pekkanen’s The Women in White starts with a graduate student casually quizzing his young wife with a deck of cards, and it’s easy to assume that’s the kind of thing a novelist invents to get a plot rolling. It isn’t though – not in this case. The novel is inspired by the real parapsychology research once done at Duke University, and the quotes that open the chapters are real and verifiable. If you finished The Women in White and wondered how much of that world actually existed, the answer is more than you’d expect, and the true story makes a better psychology lesson than a ghost story.

A real lab at a real university

The man behind the research was J.B. Rhine, a botanist who traded plants for the paranormal after attending a séance he found unconvincing. He arrived at Duke in 1927, and by 1930 he had founded a Parapsychology Laboratory under the sponsorship of the psychologist William McDougall. In 1934 he published Extra-Sensory Perception, which declared ESP an actual and demonstrable occurrence and gave the field its name in America. Rhine wasn’t a fringe figure working out of a basement. He had a university’s backing, a journal of his own, and a wife, Louisa, who collected stories of spontaneous psychic experiences while he handled the lab work. That respectable setting is what makes the fictional Trimble Institute in The Women in White feel believable, because the real thing looked just as legitimate from the outside.

What the Zener cards actually tested

The cards that appear in the novel are Zener cards, designed by Rhine’s Duke colleague Karl Zener. A deck holds twenty-five cards, five each of five simple symbols: a star, a circle, a cross, a set of wavy lines, and a square. A person guesses the hidden card, and since there are five symbols, pure chance should land about one correct guess in five. Anyone who consistently beats that number looks interesting, which is exactly how the novel’s Betty catches the attention of her husband’s mentor. In the real lab, the most famous results came from a student named Hubert Pearce, who was tested in 1933 and 1934 while sitting in a library cubicle a couple hundred yards from the researcher turning the cards. Rhine was thrilled whenever someone beat the odds by a wide margin, and that excitement turns out to be the first psychological red flag.

Where the science fell apart

Critics found problems almost immediately. Some of the early decks were thin enough that symbols could reportedly be seen through the paper. Hand shuffling wasn’t random enough to rule out predictable patterns. The deck’s structure also made guessing slightly easier than the one-in-five odds suggest, since every card removed changes the probabilities for the ones left. Researchers at other universities tried to repeat Rhine’s results and mostly couldn’t. When a magician was brought in to watch Pearce, his scores reportedly dropped to chance levels. Rhine himself disclosed in 1974 that he’d found cases of experimenter unreliability in his own lab. After retiring from Duke in 1965, he continued his work at an independent foundation, and card-guessing studies eventually fell out of favor with parapsychologists themselves.

Why smart people believed anyway

This is the part that gives the novel its psychological edge. Rhine and his team weren’t stupid, and most of them weren’t frauds. They were people who wanted a result badly, and wanting a result is one of the most reliable ways to find it. Confirmation bias lets a researcher count the hits as meaningful and the misses as an off day. The researchers also had a cherished subject to protect, and those subjects tended to score highest when conditions were loosest. Experimenter bias, the way a researcher’s expectations can quietly steer an outcome, was only starting to be understood as a real threat to research in that era. Modern psychology treats these as the exact problems that careful design is meant to prevent, which is why the field now relies on blinding, preregistration, and replication. In 2011, psychologist Daryl Bem published a paper claiming evidence that people could sense future events, and it helped ignite the replication crisis in psychology, which is a pretty direct echo of the Duke story.

Why the story still works as fiction

What The Women in White does well is separate the question of whether ESP is real from the question of what happens to people when a researcher decides he already knows the answer. You can be a total skeptic and still find the novel disturbing, because the real danger in the book isn’t the paranormal. It’s a man with authority, a hypothesis he’s attached to, and subjects he’s stopped treating as people. That’s also what made some actual twentieth-century experiments so troubling, and it’s why research ethics rules exist today. Pekkanen takes a real piece of academic history, one that most of us only half remember from an intro psychology lecture, and asks what it would have felt like to be the person holding the cards.

If you enjoy historical thrillers with a real-world foundation, or you’re the kind of reader who finishes a novel and immediately goes looking up the facts behind it, this one rewards the digging. And if you loved the psychology angle in The Women in White, the history of the Duke lab is worth an afternoon of reading on its own.


Discover more from itsm3g

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top