Light spoilers for the setup and a few scenes from the first half of the film. Nothing about how it ends.

One of the first things we learn about Chris, the dying CIA officer at the center of Wild Horse Nine, is that he plans to write a memoir that could embarrass some very powerful people, and that he’d like to open it with a meditation on whether there were vegetarian dinosaurs in heaven. John Malkovich plays him with his usual unnerving glare, and Chris is suffering from cancer-related dementia, which means he’s liable to forget he’s dying at all. It’s 1973, shortly before the Chilean coup, and he and his protégé Lee (Sam Rockwell) have been sent to Easter Island by their boss, MJ (Steve Buscemi). The central dilemma is as dark as they come: Lee has to decide whether he would kill his friend because the friend asked him to or because MJ ordered it. Yet the movie is constantly funny, sometimes at exactly the moments when laughing feels like it should be against the rules.

That reaction deserves a closer look, because Martin McDonagh has built a whole career on it. In Bruges, Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri, and The Banshees of Inisherin all ask us to laugh at guilt, grief, and violence, and Wild Horse Nine adds a dying spy and a lonely island full of enormous stone faces to the pile. If you walked out of the theater wondering why you were chuckling through a story about a man trying to make peace with a lifetime of terrible things, you’re in good company, and psychology has quite a bit to say about why.

The Psychology of Laughing at Things That Aren’t Funny

The most useful framework I know for dark comedy is the benign violation theory, proposed by researchers Peter McGraw and Caleb Warren. Their idea is that humor shows up when something feels wrong, threatening, or taboo yet feels safe or harmless at the same time. Take away the violation, and you’ve got a pleasant but boring moment, and take away the safety, and you’ve got plain distress. Death is about the biggest violation there is, so a comedy about it only works if the audience has enough distance to feel safe, and fiction hands us that distance automatically. We know Chris isn’t real, we know it’s a movie set decades ago, and we know McDonagh’s sense of timing is going to land the joke before the dread arrives. The laugh is what happens when both signals fire together.

Freud noticed something similar nearly a century ago in his essay on humor, where he used the example of a condemned man being led to the gallows on a Monday who remarks that the week is off to a nice start. Freud read a joke like that as the mind refusing to be overwhelmed, a small act of defiance against a situation that is otherwise beyond anyone’s control. That’s the same energy behind a dying man who wants to see some giant statues before he goes, and who cheerfully ignores the fact that his memoir could get him killed before his illness does.

Gallows Humor as a Survival Skill

Gallows humor isn’t only a literary device, either. Studies of emergency responders, nurses, and soldiers keep finding that people who face death regularly tend to develop dark, even cynical humor, and that it does real work: it lets them process what they see without being flattened by it, and it bonds them to the people who share the same experience. Chris and Lee are colleagues who have spent years doing violent work for an agency that doesn’t much care about them, so of course their default setting is banter. The first third of the film is mostly the two of them talking about women, marriages, and which countries have the best cheese, and it plays as light, almost surface-level conversation. It also works like a cover story, since two men who have spent their careers in secrets and coded language know exactly how to talk for an hour without saying the thing that’s sitting between them.

Is It Okay to Laugh at Chris?

The harder question is whether we should be laughing at a man with dementia, and the film clearly knows we’re asking it. A lot of Chris’s funniest moments come from lapses: forgetting that he’s dying, changing his mind about where he wants to spend his last days, announcing his memoir plans with total confidence while Lee points out that he can’t remember anything. The line between laughing at a person and laughing at a situation is thin, and it usually comes down to whether the person keeps his dignity. McDonagh never lets Chris become only a punchline. Malkovich can move from silly to menacing in the space of a sentence, and that keeps us from settling into either pity or mockery. We laugh, we wince a second later, and the wince is the film telling us we were right to feel both.

When Jokes Become a Way of Dodging

Humor researchers (which – side note – doesn’t this sound like an incredible job?) distinguish between styles of humor, and the findings tend to say that humor which brings people together or helps someone keep perspective is linked to better coping, while humor used to put people down or avoid feelings is not. Dark comedy sits right on that border. The same joke can be a release valve or a way of changing the subject, and Wild Horse Nine shows both sides. Chris and Lee keep the conversation silly because a serious one would mean admitting what MJ has asked of Lee and what Chris already half-knows. When Lee tells his friend, without much conviction, that dying makes everyone lonely wherever they are, it sounds like a throwaway joke, but it’s the most sincere thing in the scene. The film lets the humor carry these two men for a while and then lets it run out, and as MJ tightens his grip, the whole story turns darker and more claustrophobic.

That, to me, is the real answer to why we laugh at death in movies like this. Laughter gives us a way to stand close to something frightening without looking away, and a good dark comedy uses that closeness to show us what the characters are avoiding. Wild Horse Nine is one of the sharper examples I’ve seen, because the jokes are never just decoration. They’re how Chris and Lee talk about the things they can’t say directly.

Who Should Watch Wild Horse Nine

If you loved In Bruges or The Banshees of Inisherin, this one is an easy recommendation, since it shares their talky, theatrical style and their fascination with two men stuck together and haunted by what they’ve done. It’s also a good pick for anyone whose first instinct in a crisis is to make a joke, because the film understands that instinct better than most. It’s rated R for language, strong violence, drug use, and sexual references, and it runs about an hour and fifty-six minutes, so it’s not a light evening, even if it’s a funny one.


Discover more from itsm3g

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top