Most true crime documentaries ask you to do one thing, which is to be afraid of the person on screen. Aileen: Queen of the Serial Killers asks for something harder and more uncomfortable, which is to hold two truths at once. Aileen Wuornos killed seven men in central Florida between 1989 and 1990, was convicted of six of those murders, and was executed in 2002. She was also a person with a long history of abuse and neglect who was treated, by large parts of the system that judged her, as something other than a person at all. I came away from Emily Turner’s documentary convinced that the justice system did her wrong, and I’m still working out how to say that without it sounding like I’m excusing what she did.
Hearing Aileen Wuornos Speak for Herself
The most effective choice in Aileen: Queen of the Serial Killers is what it leaves out. There are no experts in leather chairs explaining her psychology to you. Instead, the film is built from archival footage, courtroom video, police tapes, Dateline reporter Michele Gillen’s coverage, and death row interviews with Wuornos herself, some of them conducted by filmmaker Jasmine Hirst. Hearing her talk, sometimes flippantly about things that would devastate most people, changes the experience of watching. You’re not being told who she was by someone with a theory. You’re listening to her try to explain herself, with all the contradictions, mood swings, and bursts of charisma that come with it, and it becomes very hard to keep her in the neat box of “monster” that the title seems to promise.
That tension is the point of the film, and it’s what made me uncomfortable in a way I think was intended. The story moves through her childhood, her relationship with Tyria Moore, the killings, the self-defense claim she later retracted, and the strange period when born-again Christian Arlene Pralle adopted her.
The Prosecutor and the Problem of Dehumanization
The part that got to me most was hearing the prosecutor talk about her as if she were less than human. It was disgusting to watch. Psychologists who study dehumanization have shown that when we strip someone of their humanity in our minds, whether by calling them an animal, a monster, or something beyond redemption, it becomes psychologically easier to justify treating them in ways we’d never accept for another person. It’s a shortcut that lets a system, or a jury, or a viewer at home, skip the hard work of reckoning with who someone actually was. Wuornos seems to have been dehumanized long before she ever reached a courtroom, and the documentary shows how the legal process finished the job.
What makes this so frustrating is that she didn’t pretend otherwise about what she’d done. She admitted that it was wrong and that she should be punished. A person who says that is not asking to be let off the hook, and the prosecutor’s contempt reads even worse against that backdrop. Accountability is supposed to be the thing a justice system offers in exchange for a confession, and here it came wrapped in the language of disgust.
Why Sympathy Isn’t the Same as Excusing
There’s a reason this kind of sympathy feels so uncomfortable, and it’s tied to how our brains like to sort people. Researchers have described something called moral typecasting, where we tend to see people as either villains who do harm or victims who suffer it, and we struggle to let someone be both. Wuornos is a textbook case of someone who doesn’t fit. She was harmed repeatedly, and she harmed others, and Aileen: Queen of the Serial Killers refuses to resolve that for you. If you feel pity, the guilt of feeling it follows right behind, because the victims and their families are real, too.
I don’t think the answer is to turn the sympathy off. Feeling for someone doesn’t cancel out the people she killed, and it doesn’t mean she should have walked free. It means you can believe in accountability and still insist that the person being held accountable deserves to be treated as a human being, which is a much lower bar than it sounds like. The documentary isn’t perfect, and some critics have pointed out that it touches on the self-defense claim, false confessions, and the death penalty without digging deep into any of them. The collage structure can also feel scattered at times. But the way it centers her voice made me think harder about the system than most documentaries in this genre do.
Who Should Watch Aileen: Queen of the Serial Killers
I’d recommend it to true crime fans who are tired of the standard formula and want something that sits with the uncomfortable parts instead of rushing past them. If you’ve seen Monster or Nick Broomfield’s earlier Wuornos documentaries, this one adds new death row material and a more reflective tone. It isn’t a comfortable watch, but it left me with more to think about than most of what Netflix has put out in the genre lately.
Discover more from itsm3g
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
